Jul 04 2007

2,250 Sandpoints = 1 Shanghai

Sandpoint Skyline

One week ago I left Shanghai behind and my wife and I began our annual migration back to our summer stomping grounds, the Pacific Northwest. After 10 months living and working in a city of 18 million people with an industrial sector that ensures 365 days a year of a thick haze blank over the Shanghai, nothing is more refreshing than returning to the nearly empty mountains of North Idaho (“It’s a state of mind” is what they say around here).

Some of the highlights of life in Northern Idaho include the excessively blue skies, the sparkling Lake Pend O’reille, the ever green slopes of the Selkirk mountains, the bears, moose and deer with whom we share our beautiful trails, and finally the intimate sense of community that infuses the local economy of Sandpoint, our home town of 8,000 (you’d need 2,250 Sandpoints to make one Shanghai!).

In Shanghai, foreigners mostly shop at one or two boutique foreign grocery stores, packed full of processed foods imported from Europe, North America, Japan, Australia and other far corners of the earth. About the only things you’ll find that are “local” in these markets is the produce, which itself is of suspect quality given the large quantities of chemicals banned in most western countries used by Chinese farmers (not to mention the continued use of human feces as a fertilizer).

To eat like a foreigner in Shanghai is to be an active participant in the global, industrial food chain. The manufacture of the processed foods imported from the West involved industrial processes far beyond the comprehension of most consumers. The use of petro-chemicals infuses every step of this process, from the chemical fertilizers, herbicides, fungicides, pesticides and insecticides to the chemical preservatives to the petroleum burned getting the food from field to factory to warehouse to container ship to grocery store thousands of miles away. To eat like a foreigner in Shanghai is to contribute to the degradation of our environment, the warming of our atmosphere, and the destruction of a traditional way of life for local family farmers all over the West, as factory farms proliferate across the West’s fertile lands. Despite all this, my wife and I still eat like foreigners in Shanghai, and attempt to suspend our conscience while we participate in the industrial food chain we so despise.

For my wife, Liz, and I, returning to Sandpoint, Idaho is an act not only of spiritual and physical rejuvenation, but also of economic emancipation. We are freed from the destructive global industrial food chain on which we depend as foreigners living in China. To eat in Sandpoint is to participate in a sustainable, local, environmentally friendly food chain where organic, locally grown foods are available in every grocery store.

Our first stop when returning to Sandpoint is always Winter Ridge Organics, followed by a trip to Woods Ranch Meat Processing Plant (for me, as my wife is a vegetarian). Woods Ranch presents an interesting study in local foods. All of the meat processed at this small plant nestled in between Idaho’s Selkirk Mountains and the Cabinet Mountains of Western Montana is raised in the rich grasslands of the Pack and Kootenai river valleys. In addition to grass fed beef, this plant processes and sells direct to the consumer pork, buffalo, and game meat such as elk and venison. During the hunting seasons it is not unusual to find bear and moose in their freezers, as the region’s mountains present local hunters with a plethora of wild game.

Shanghai Skyline

When I compare the intricate and energy intensive food chain of the foreign eater in Shanghai with the short, direct food chain of the local eater in Sandpoint (along the dirt road to Woods Ranch you pass the very cattle that are processed therein), I begin to wonder how our economy has woven such a tangled web of international trade and commerce. I am also thankful that I am in a position where I get to observe and participate in both extremes of the modern economy, both the local and the global. As a teacher of economics, this perspective may prove valuable as my students and I strive to put the complex web of today’s economy into focus.

Ultimately, I can say I wish I could have the best of both worlds. I wish I could take my wonderful job and school and classroom and students of my life in Shanghai and “import” them all to Sandpoint, Idaho. I wish we could all enjoy a more l

ocal existence; but the prospects of this way of life surviving seem weaker every year I return. A couple of summers ago the town just north of Sandpoint opened the first Wal-Mart in Northern Idaho. Reality check: globalization is everywhere! China haunts my idyllic summer paradise; I cannot escape it! At least the haze of Shanghai has not stretched its ugly reach to the Selkirk mountains, not yet, at least…

Powered by ScribeFire.


About the author:  Jason Welker teaches International Baccalaureate and Advanced Placement Economics at Zurich International School in Switzerland. In addition to publishing various online resources for economics students and teachers, Jason developed the online version of the Economics course for the IB and is has authored two Economics textbooks: Pearson Baccalaureate’s Economics for the IB Diploma and REA’s AP Macroeconomics Crash Course. Jason is a native of the Pacific Northwest of the United States, and is a passionate adventurer, who considers himself a skier / mountain biker who teaches Economics in his free time. He and his wife keep a ski chalet in the mountains of Northern Idaho, which now that they live in the Swiss Alps gets far too little use. Read more posts by this author

16 responses so far

16 Responses to “2,250 Sandpoints = 1 Shanghai”

  1. Marco Garofaloon 05 Aug 2007 at 11:01 am

    As Mr. Welker pointed out, Sandpoint is a perfect example of a village that so far has been more or less preserved from the process of globalization. Globalization in this sense has been centralizing and homogenising the food chain. The whole point of a chain store such as Wal-Mart is that you can find the same product at any location. This is in contrast to the example of the “short, direct food chain of the local eater in Sandpoint”. The “destructive, global industrial food chain” on which Mr. Welker and many of us ex-pats depend has flourished and sustained because of our priorities. We find the opportunity cost of missing out on the western foods too great, that we tolerate the “intricate and energy intensive food chain,” which we find in Shanghai.

    Obviously, one cannot “import” the urban life of Shanghai into a small rural Sandpoint setting. That is a wish. It is a want. Economics is compromising with your wants. It is making the choices and explaining these choices that we make in our lives. What is it that we, as individuals, value more? Dynamic life in Shanghai with a despicable industrial food chain, or simple rural life with some of the finer things in life?

  2. Ennoon 08 Aug 2007 at 6:47 pm

    wow. I can't believe ur actually doing the work…

  3. Cassy Changon 10 Aug 2007 at 10:21 pm

    I think I see a pattern in how ppl prioritize things in life: first they establish their careers, fulfil their ambitions of success, then reflect on the quality of life. It corresponds to the hierarchy of needs in a way.

  4. Conrad Liuon 11 Aug 2007 at 12:53 pm

    From the article that I just read, it seems that soon no place will be save from the chains of globalization. Even small rural towns are beginning to succumb to the globalization, as can be seen in Sandpoint. It really is a shame that having some areas free from such a "world policy" can only be a dream, a unfulfillable desire.

  5. Katherine Yangon 12 Aug 2007 at 12:13 am

    Globalization, whilst it can be a good thing, it's also a scary thing. When I think of globalization , I think of a dark cloud of pollution, because that's what usually comes with it. Even the places such as Guiling with all its beautiful mountains is becoming polluted because tourists, means more shops and transportation, means more carbon monoxide (from buses that transport the tourists, from factories that manufacture the gift shop junk, from the trucks that ship everthing back and forth). This all happens because globalization brings money, and who doesn't want more money? Then only after lung cancer and asthma rates increase and people can no longer see the stars and the moon is small er than a penny, do people look back and dream about the finer points of rural life.

  6. Jenny Kimon 15 Aug 2007 at 12:18 am

    Just like what Mr.Welker said, because of globalization, most places in the world are booming with foriegn things; foreign restaurants, schools, shops…etc. It's a shame how globalization makes local things disappear.

  7. Melanie Chuon 18 Aug 2007 at 5:37 pm

    i think the starbucks in Beijing in the Forbidden City really really degrades the whole atmosphere. Its good that they shut it down, but what Mr. Welker said is true, globalization is everywhere. It seems that there is no where you can turn without seeing a Starbucks. Hey, there's even one near school, but who's complaining? In the modern city, many people would rather have their starbucks then give up their comfortable neccessities to go out with in the wild.

  8. […] 2,250 Sandpoints = 1 Shanghai […]

  9. tavoli da gioco pokeron 15 Nov 2007 at 10:04 pm

    casinos en ligne…

    Comment tavoli da gioco poker meilleures promotions en ligne…

  10. freispiele faire spiele frei spieleon 16 Nov 2007 at 12:46 am

    faire spiele…

    Ich spielebank spiel konto…

  11. meilleures salles de jeuxon 16 Nov 2007 at 2:13 am

    meilleures salles de jeux…

    En general meilleures salles de jeux web poker…

  12. jouer à la rouletteon 18 Nov 2007 at 4:36 am

    play poker omaha free…

  13. advance cash loan payday advance cash cash loan loan payday quick payday payday loan cash advance loan…

    If cash advance payday loan payday cash loan…

  14. vincere alla roulette on lineon 20 Nov 2007 at 8:02 pm

    casino on line roulette…

  15. ringtone polifonico legal gratuitaon 02 Feb 2008 at 3:39 pm

    ringtone grátis…

    You ringtone celular gratuito ringtone música celular grátis…

  16. keypress motorola ringtoneson 05 Feb 2008 at 2:11 am

    keypress motorola ringtones…

    Create info monophonic motorola remember ringtones citibank secured credit card…